Edgette
ONE love, blood, life
Has anyone noticed that opening guitar parts to both of these songs are the same? Does anyone know why? Edge wasn't getting lazy on us was he?
kevink said:I think they took the opening from Is That All? and added it to The Electric Co. for the live version.
Originally posted by
Is that All is the BEST possible ending for one of U2's BEST albums!!!
Originally posted by
yeah, sorry to just repeat what's said but they basically played the Cry at the beginning of The Electric Co. when playing the song Live and obviously thought it would be a good riff to use for another song on 'October'...and it IS!
Is that All is the BEST possible ending for one of U2's BEST albums!!!
TCUFrog said:the intro for "is that all" was used in the live version of the electric co. the intro for electric co was not used in "is that all"
Popmartijn said:
And that is your opinion, of course.
I think that during the recording of October U2 were really fighting against a deadline (back when they didn't have the power to let it just pass) and had to come up with another song. Out of desperation they used the instrumental beginning of The Electric Co. (dubbed The Cry) so they didn't have to spend any more time at coming up with a melody. But that does not mean it is a good ending for a U2 album.
C ya!
Marty