I went to college in Waukesha, and picking up a paper copy of The Onion each week was the best. Last time I was in Milwaukee about 4-5 years ago, it was right before they stopped the print version, and that made me sad. But at least I got to pick up one last copy. I actually sent my resume to The Onion when I graduated and they wanted me to interview, but for whatever lame reason I had at the time, I didn't follow through. (I think I just had a massive bout of wishy-washiness at graduation, flailing because I had no idea what I wanted to do.)
I do like AV Club a lot, although I really, really miss the old site. This Disqus business is awful and it's so hard to find anything.
There's usually a lot of good conversation in the comments when U2 comes up there, though. At least in the old format. I think the commenting has really dropped off with the new format.