Early Song Rankings
- Thread starter Jarvio
- Start date
The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
I’m not understanding the point of the deluxe songs. OL has no business on this record. It’s a blatant appeal to a recent mild success. LOH is a cool but unnecessary remix. BOYH sounds like what it is - a half cooked demo better served on a compilation down the line. And Kygo? Forget it.
1. Achtung Baby 10/10
2. The Joshua Tree 9.5/10
3. The Unforgettable Fire 8.5/10
4. War 8/10
5. Pop 7.5/10
6. Rattle & Hum 7/10
7. Zooropa 7/10
8. All That You Can’t Leave Behind 6.5/10
9. Boy 6/10
10. Songs Of Experience 6/10
11. October 5.5/10
12. How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb 5.5/10
13. No Line On The Horizon 5/10
14. Songs Of Innocence 4/10
2. The Joshua Tree 9.5/10
3. The Unforgettable Fire 8.5/10
4. War 8/10
5. Pop 7.5/10
6. Rattle & Hum 7/10
7. Zooropa 7/10
8. All That You Can’t Leave Behind 6.5/10
9. Boy 6/10
10. Songs Of Experience 6/10
11. October 5.5/10
12. How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb 5.5/10
13. No Line On The Horizon 5/10
14. Songs Of Innocence 4/10
Sken
Refugee
- Joined
- Sep 10, 2001
- Messages
- 1,042
Standouts
Landlady
Lights of Home
Book of Your Heart
Red Flag Day
Little Things That Give You Away
Good
Love is Bigger Than Anything In Its Way
Summer of Love
Get Out Of Your Own Way
The Showman
Love is All We Have Left
Ok
13
You’re the Best Thing About Me
Blackout (would be higher if not for the rhymes and lame chorus, walrus)
Garbage
American Soul
Landlady
Lights of Home
Book of Your Heart
Red Flag Day
Little Things That Give You Away
Good
Love is Bigger Than Anything In Its Way
Summer of Love
Get Out Of Your Own Way
The Showman
Love is All We Have Left
Ok
13
You’re the Best Thing About Me
Blackout (would be higher if not for the rhymes and lame chorus, walrus)
Garbage
American Soul
jimmy barbour
Babyface
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2017
- Messages
- 1
My favourite is American soul think it’s gonna be a belter live next year
Have been through approx 1.75 listens of the album. None of the songs completely blow me away, nor do I think any will be referred to as "iconic" U2 songs years down the road. For me, it's currently like this:
Great songs:
Love is all we have Left
Summer of Love
The Blackout
13 (There is a Light)
The Little Things...
Honorable mention to bonus tracks: Book of your heart and Strings version of Lights
Good Songs:
Lights of Home
Best Thing (it's growing on me)
American Soul (rework some of the lyrics and it becomes great)
Landlady
Indifferent (take-or-leave):
Get Out of Your Own Way
Love is Bigger
Not enjoying much:
Red Flag Day
The Showman
Lastly, as far as the two other deluxe edition bonus tracks go:
Ordinary Love was unnecessary to remix. It's a classic, to me, and should have made the SOI cut.
TBT (Kygo) - The best version of this song; breathes life into it. I'd love the Strings version of Lights followed by this on the album proper.
Great songs:
Love is all we have Left
Summer of Love
The Blackout
13 (There is a Light)
The Little Things...
Honorable mention to bonus tracks: Book of your heart and Strings version of Lights
Good Songs:
Lights of Home
Best Thing (it's growing on me)
American Soul (rework some of the lyrics and it becomes great)
Landlady
Indifferent (take-or-leave):
Get Out of Your Own Way
Love is Bigger
Not enjoying much:
Red Flag Day
The Showman
Lastly, as far as the two other deluxe edition bonus tracks go:
Ordinary Love was unnecessary to remix. It's a classic, to me, and should have made the SOI cut.
TBT (Kygo) - The best version of this song; breathes life into it. I'd love the Strings version of Lights followed by this on the album proper.
Nate Dogg
Refugee
Early ranking:
Red Flag Day
Little Things
Summer of Love
Showman
Landlady
Love is All We Have Left
Blackout
Book of Your Heart
13
Best Thing
Get Out of Your Own Way
Love is Bigger
American Soul
Red Flag Day
Little Things
Summer of Love
Showman
Landlady
Love is All We Have Left
Blackout
Book of Your Heart
13
Best Thing
Get Out of Your Own Way
Love is Bigger
American Soul
purpleoscar
Rock n' Roll Doggie ALL ACCESS
U2 is not against any of this, and lots of fans like the Kygo mix and even like it better than the original. Just rip what you like and make a new mix. Give people everything and let them make their own tracklists.
xtrmx
War Child
I would've loved if the album just finished at #13, anything that comes after just feels way out of place and detracts from the album itself. Of course it's a deluxe version but still, feels it ruins the great closer 13 actually is. It's so early rating anyway that I didn't even know which title belongs to which song yet.
Just glad I like this album way more already than the last one, when the only song reaching "good" was Song for Someone.
Love
13
Good
Love is All We Have Left
Lights of Home
You're the Best Thing About Me
Red Flag Day
The Little Things that Give You Away
Landlady
Ok
Get Out of Your Own Way
Don't Like at all / mehhh
Summer of Love
The Showman
The Blackout
Love Is Bigger Than Anything In Its Way
Worst U2 Song Ever Already
American Soul
As for Albums so far:
Love
HTDAAB / UF / AB / POP / JT / ATYCLB / Zooropa
Good
NLOTH
Ok
October / War / Songs of Experience / Boy
Shit Tier
Rattle and a Hum / Songs of Innocence
Just glad I like this album way more already than the last one, when the only song reaching "good" was Song for Someone.
Love
13
Good
Love is All We Have Left
Lights of Home
You're the Best Thing About Me
Red Flag Day
The Little Things that Give You Away
Landlady
Ok
Get Out of Your Own Way
Don't Like at all / mehhh
Summer of Love
The Showman
The Blackout
Love Is Bigger Than Anything In Its Way
Worst U2 Song Ever Already
American Soul
As for Albums so far:
Love
HTDAAB / UF / AB / POP / JT / ATYCLB / Zooropa
Good
NLOTH
Ok
October / War / Songs of Experience / Boy
Shit Tier
Rattle and a Hum / Songs of Innocence
Last edited:
mikal
Blue Crack Addict
The Little Things That Give You Away
Love Is Bigger Than Anything Else In Its Way
The Blackout
Get Out Of Your Own Way
Red Flag Day
Lights Of Home
Love Is All That We Have Left
Landlady
Summer Of Love
13
You’re The Best Thing About Me
The Showman
American Soul
Love Is Bigger Than Anything Else In Its Way
The Blackout
Get Out Of Your Own Way
Red Flag Day
Lights Of Home
Love Is All That We Have Left
Landlady
Summer Of Love
13
You’re The Best Thing About Me
The Showman
American Soul
Nate Dogg
Refugee
SeanEG26
The Fly
The Little Things That Give You Away
Love Is All We Have Left
The Blackout
Love Is Bigger Than Anything In Its Way
Summer of Love
Lights Of Home
13
Landlady
Get Out Of Your Own Way
Red Flag Day
The Showman
American Soul
You're The Best Thing About Me
Those last 4 could really be put in any order. Not a fan of any of them. If I were to include Book of Your Heart it'd probably be only slightly above that group. Still, out of 13 songs, I consider 9 of them to be anywhere from good to great. Pretty damn good.
Love Is All We Have Left
The Blackout
Love Is Bigger Than Anything In Its Way
Summer of Love
Lights Of Home
13
Landlady
Get Out Of Your Own Way
Red Flag Day
The Showman
American Soul
You're The Best Thing About Me
Those last 4 could really be put in any order. Not a fan of any of them. If I were to include Book of Your Heart it'd probably be only slightly above that group. Still, out of 13 songs, I consider 9 of them to be anywhere from good to great. Pretty damn good.
gweeps
War Child
Last ranking for now. Moving Book of Your Heart above The Blackout.
Get out of your own way (unpopular choice, I know)
The little things that give you away
13 (there is a light)
The book of your heart
Lights of home
Summer of Love
The Blackout (great vibe, but still find the chorus a little too weak)
Love is all we have left
The showman
Love is bigger than anything in it's way
You're the best thing about me
Landlady
- small gap -
Red Flag Day
- HUGE gap-
American Soul
The little things that give you away
13 (there is a light)
The book of your heart
Lights of home
Summer of Love
The Blackout (great vibe, but still find the chorus a little too weak)
Love is all we have left
The showman
Love is bigger than anything in it's way
You're the best thing about me
Landlady
- small gap -
Red Flag Day
- HUGE gap-
American Soul
CosmoKramer
Rock n' Roll Doggie
- Joined
- Aug 19, 2004
- Messages
- 3,325
Funny that some of the songs in your bottom half are at the top of my list (summer of love, Love is Bigger, Get out of, TBT) and yet we both have the same top song (at least at this point).
Little Things is special!
CosmoKramer
Rock n' Roll Doggie
- Joined
- Aug 19, 2004
- Messages
- 3,325
You and I have the same top 4 in order!
Little Things
Love is Bigger
Blackout
Get Out of your own way
Summer of Love
Red Flag Day
Best Thing
Land Lady
American Soul
13
Light of Home
Showman
Love is All We Have Left
The above list WILL change but those top 2 songs are staying 1-2 they just might swap.
riteshbhatt1
The Fly
- Joined
- Jul 25, 2000
- Messages
- 283
Have had a chance to listen all weekend after my Friday midnight first listen. My rankings right now.
Absolutely Love:
1. The Little Things That Give You Away
2. Summer Of Love
3. Red Flag Day
4. The Blackout
5. Landlady
Great songs:
6.Lights Of Home
7. 13
8. Love Is All That We Have Left
9. Love Is Bigger Than Anything Else In Its Way
Good songs but not standouts
10. Get Out Of Your Own Way
11. The Showman
12. You’re The Best Thing About Me
Enjoyable but will skip in the future
13. American Soul
I would put Book of Your Heart in my "Great songs" too!
Absolutely Love:
1. The Little Things That Give You Away
2. Summer Of Love
3. Red Flag Day
4. The Blackout
5. Landlady
Great songs:
6.Lights Of Home
7. 13
8. Love Is All That We Have Left
9. Love Is Bigger Than Anything Else In Its Way
Good songs but not standouts
10. Get Out Of Your Own Way
11. The Showman
12. You’re The Best Thing About Me
Enjoyable but will skip in the future
13. American Soul
I would put Book of Your Heart in my "Great songs" too!
rosephile
Refugee
Favorite part of the album is Little Things through Blackout.
I like nearly the whole thing; really looking forward to seeing this album in concert.
Least faves are Lights of Home and most least fave is The Showman (Little More Better), purely for the aural distaste it causes. They're not terrible, I just don't care for them and wish they'd James-Bonded-up a different song for the bonus track.
One popular one to hate on, You're the Best Thing About Me, I'll always have a fondness for due to being in front of Bono when they played it in Kansas City and seeing how damn HAPPY he looked that people already knew a lot of the words. I can't argue with close-up Bono!joy.
American Soul just sounds like something from HTDAAB and while I acknowledge it's not the BEST, I relate to the message and appreciate the bittersweet nostalgia to that album/tour, as it was when I finally saw U2 for the first time.
Oh, yeah!
Landlady
The Little Things that Give You Away
The Blackout
Yeah Yeah Yeah (Yeah Yeah Yeah Yeah Yeah!)
13 (There is a Light)
Red Flag Day
Yes, Please
Love is Bigger than Anything in its Way
Book of Your Heart
Love is All We Have Left
Get Out of Your Own Way
Summer of Love
You're the Best Thing about Me
American Soul
I Shall Skip Thee When No One Objects
Lights of Home
The Showman (Little More Better)
I like nearly the whole thing; really looking forward to seeing this album in concert.
Least faves are Lights of Home and most least fave is The Showman (Little More Better), purely for the aural distaste it causes. They're not terrible, I just don't care for them and wish they'd James-Bonded-up a different song for the bonus track.
One popular one to hate on, You're the Best Thing About Me, I'll always have a fondness for due to being in front of Bono when they played it in Kansas City and seeing how damn HAPPY he looked that people already knew a lot of the words. I can't argue with close-up Bono!joy.
American Soul just sounds like something from HTDAAB and while I acknowledge it's not the BEST, I relate to the message and appreciate the bittersweet nostalgia to that album/tour, as it was when I finally saw U2 for the first time.
Oh, yeah!
Landlady
The Little Things that Give You Away
The Blackout
Yeah Yeah Yeah (Yeah Yeah Yeah Yeah Yeah!)
13 (There is a Light)
Red Flag Day
Yes, Please
Love is Bigger than Anything in its Way
Book of Your Heart
Love is All We Have Left
Get Out of Your Own Way
Summer of Love
You're the Best Thing about Me
American Soul
I Shall Skip Thee When No One Objects
Lights of Home
The Showman (Little More Better)
I’m with you! Surprised how low most have GOOYOW.
My early rankings...
1. GOOYOW
2. Lights of Home
3. Red Flag Day
4. The Showman
5. Landlady
6. Little Things
7. Love is Bigger
8. Summer of Love
9. Love is All
10. You’re the Best Thing
11. American Soul
12. Blackout
13. 13
This album continues to grow, however. And some songs I didn’t like initially (landlady) have shot up the rankings for me. Lesson to all: keep listening!
NintendoFan204
The Fly
An update after a couple more listens:
1. Red Flag Day
2. Summer of Love
3. Lights of Home
4. The Little Things That Give You Away
5. Get Out Of Your Own Way
6. The Showman (Little More Better)
7. You're The Best Thing About Me
8. Love Is All We Have Left
9. American Soul
10. 13 (There is A Light)
11. Love Is Bigger Than Anything In It's Way
12. The Blackout
13. Book Of Your Heart
14. Landlady
No clear standout and a lot that are very close together. This is getting harder to rank. I expect things to keep shifting.
1. Red Flag Day
2. Summer of Love
3. Lights of Home
4. The Little Things That Give You Away
5. Get Out Of Your Own Way
6. The Showman (Little More Better)
7. You're The Best Thing About Me
8. Love Is All We Have Left
9. American Soul
10. 13 (There is A Light)
11. Love Is Bigger Than Anything In It's Way
12. The Blackout
13. Book Of Your Heart
14. Landlady
No clear standout and a lot that are very close together. This is getting harder to rank. I expect things to keep shifting.
kiwilad
Refugee
You're a horrible person. If you're even a person. Maybe you're not a person. Just a horrible.
Horrible.
NintendoFan204
The Fly
But I like the song! It might grow on me a lot as time goes by. I've had my least favorite song on an album become one of my favorites as time went by. It's just the least interesting to me as of my first three listens.
kiwilad
Refugee
Hmmm. I'll be watching you.
NintendoFan204
The Fly
1. Love Is Bigger Than Anything In Its Way - 9/10
2. The Little Things That Give You Away - 8/10
3. Red Flag Day - 8/10
4. Summer of Love - 7.5/10
5. 13 (There Is A Light) - 7.5/10
6. Love Is All We Have Left - 7.5/10
7. The Showman - 7/10
8. Landlady - 6.5/10
9. Lights of Home - 6.5/10
10. You're the Best Thing About Me - 6/10
11. Get Out Of Your Own Way - 5.5/10
12. The Blackout - 4/10
13. American Soul - 2/10
2. The Little Things That Give You Away - 8/10
3. Red Flag Day - 8/10
4. Summer of Love - 7.5/10
5. 13 (There Is A Light) - 7.5/10
6. Love Is All We Have Left - 7.5/10
7. The Showman - 7/10
8. Landlady - 6.5/10
9. Lights of Home - 6.5/10
10. You're the Best Thing About Me - 6/10
11. Get Out Of Your Own Way - 5.5/10
12. The Blackout - 4/10
13. American Soul - 2/10
prbiker15
Blue Crack Addict
1 - The Little Things That Give You Away
2 - Red Flag Day
3 - The Blackout
4 - Love is Bigger Than Anything In It’s Way
5 - Lights of Home
6 - You’re the Best Thing About Me
7 - Summer of Love
8 - Book of Your Heart
9 - Love is All We Have Left
10 - Landlady
11 - The Showman
12 - Get Out of Your Own Way
13 - 13 (There is a Light)
14 - American Soul
2 - Red Flag Day
3 - The Blackout
4 - Love is Bigger Than Anything In It’s Way
5 - Lights of Home
6 - You’re the Best Thing About Me
7 - Summer of Love
8 - Book of Your Heart
9 - Love is All We Have Left
10 - Landlady
11 - The Showman
12 - Get Out of Your Own Way
13 - 13 (There is a Light)
14 - American Soul
Yahweh_OMG
New Yorker
Well.... it s a tough call. Have been listening to the album all day long. No weak track , that s 2 albums in a row.
First day ranking: (7 listenings)
1. The little things that gave you away (most u2 ish but the only one that gives me goosebumps and makes me weird... so beautiful)
2. Red flag day (is this band really close to 60?!)
3. The Blackout (loved that song from the start)
Then it gets too difficult.... The next 4 songs are at the moment on the same scale...
4-7. Lights of home
4-7. Summer of love
4-7. The Showman
4-7. Love is bigger than anything in its way
Same thing with the next 4....
8-11. Love is all we have left
8-11. American soul (would be higher without the Volcano part. I love u2 rock songs)
8-11. Landlady
8-11. 13 (too bad song for someone exists... this is much better)
12. You re the best thing about me
13. Get out of your own way
My top 3 is clear.... my bottom 2 as well.... The rest is all very solid. Not much anything they have done before.... it is surprising, sometimes makes me even smile. Next ranking after the real stuff comes with a good sound!!!
I Will quote myself not because I am a narcissistic but because my early ranking has changed a bit... and might evolve again.
Fabulous songs:
Love is all we have left
Red flag day
Book of your heart
Great songs:
Lights of home
Summer of love
The little things that gave you away
Showman
13
The Blackout
Good songs
Landlady
Love is bigger than anything in its way
Ok songs:
Amercian soul
The best thing
Crap song:
Get out of your own way
Usually i like rock songs better. Big fan of Like a song for exemple. For this album, the slower songs are so good. Love is all we have left might be my favourite right now.... and should have been 2 minutes longer.... and Book of your heart is the best b sides since Luminous Times and should have been included in the album.
Great album. I am drugged.
Last edited:
BoyOnTheHorizon
Refugee
Changing for the 3rd time:
1 - Red Flag Day
2 - Summer Of Love
3 - Lights of Home
4 - Love is Bigger Than Anything
5 - Little Things
6 - The Showman
7 - Love is all We Have Left
8 - Get out of Your Own Way
9 - 13
10 - Blackout
11 -You are the Best Thing
12 - American Soul
13 - Landlady
1 - Red Flag Day
2 - Summer Of Love
3 - Lights of Home
4 - Love is Bigger Than Anything
5 - Little Things
6 - The Showman
7 - Love is all We Have Left
8 - Get out of Your Own Way
9 - 13
10 - Blackout
11 -You are the Best Thing
12 - American Soul
13 - Landlady
Similar threads
